Forum:Ingerland/Change the country name?: Difference between revisions
(For discussion about changing the name of Ingerland) |
Lithium-Ion (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
||
Line 6: | Line 6: | ||
===Discussion=== | ===Discussion=== | ||
While I '''support''' the name change (despite previously opposing it), I firmly believe that all (or at least an overwhelming majority) mappers of Ingerish-speaking countries, and especially mappers where Ingerland is incorporated into the name, must be on board with the name change and have a chance to contribute to this discussion before anything is decided. --[[User:Lithium|Lithium-Ion]] | [https://opengeofiction.net/user/Lithium-Ion|OGF] ([[User talk:Lithium|talk]]) 17:15, 28 April 2024 (UTC) | |||
===Alternative names=== | ===Alternative names=== | ||
Line 20: | Line 19: | ||
! Comments | ! Comments | ||
! Suggested by | ! Suggested by | ||
|-valign="top" | |||
|Aecland | |||
|Aeclish | |||
|Aecodean | |||
|Aeclish | |||
| style="vertical-align:top" | Could also be "Acland". From "ac/aec" the Old English word for "oak", thus "Oak-land". If someone could come up with something to put between aec and land it could perhaps be refined further. | |||
|[[User:Lithium|Lithium-Ion]] | [https://opengeofiction.net/user/Lithium-Ion|OGF] ([[User talk:Lithium|talk]]) | |||
|-valign="top" | |-valign="top" | ||
|Anbion | |Anbion | ||
Line 34: | Line 40: | ||
| style="vertical-align:top" | A Gearmanic mis-hearing and mis-understanding of the Caeltig ''Bryn y lan'' (Hill by the shore), which they thought was referring to a whole land and not just a particular hill (similar to "Canada" coming from an Iroquois word for "village"). | | style="vertical-align:top" | A Gearmanic mis-hearing and mis-understanding of the Caeltig ''Bryn y lan'' (Hill by the shore), which they thought was referring to a whole land and not just a particular hill (similar to "Canada" coming from an Iroquois word for "village"). | ||
|[[User:Pawl|Pawl]] ([[User talk:Pawl|talk]]) | |[[User:Pawl|Pawl]] ([[User talk:Pawl|talk]]) | ||
|-valign="top" | |||
|Intherland | |||
|Intherish | |||
|Intherish | |||
|Intherish | |||
| style="vertical-align:top" | It's "Ingerland" but with a "th" instead of a "g". While it's still a pretty obvious England ripoff, it's far less egregious than before, and could possibly have an etymology related to "Hinterland" or, like England, the Inther people - whoever they are. | |||
|[[User:Lithium|Lithium-Ion]] | [https://opengeofiction.net/user/Lithium-Ion|OGF] ([[User talk:Lithium|talk]]) | |||
|} | |} | ||
[[Category:Ingerland forum posts]] | [[Category:Ingerland forum posts]] |
Revision as of 17:16, 28 April 2024
Some Ingerland mappers (and others) have expressed a preference for a change of the country's name. Reasons include that the name Ingerland sounds like rather childish parody of England, and it is associated with some of the more hooligan, extreme and racist elements of English society.
A change of name could impact quite a few other countries, especially if it changes the language name too, involving a fair number of changes to the map and wiki. So, although the decision ultimately rests with Ingerland mappers, comments and ideas from the wider community are welcome.
So ... should the country (and language) name be changed? Any ideas for alternative names? Any other considerations? -- Pawl (talk) 16:46, 28 April 2024 (UTC)
Discussion
While I support the name change (despite previously opposing it), I firmly believe that all (or at least an overwhelming majority) mappers of Ingerish-speaking countries, and especially mappers where Ingerland is incorporated into the name, must be on board with the name change and have a chance to contribute to this discussion before anything is decided. --Lithium-Ion | [1] (talk) 17:15, 28 April 2024 (UTC)
Alternative names
PLease add any suggestions you have for an alternative name (if the name is to change). Add your username in the last column by writing three tildas (~~~).
Name | Adjective | Demonym | Linguonym | Comments | Suggested by |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Aecland | Aeclish | Aecodean | Aeclish | Could also be "Acland". From "ac/aec" the Old English word for "oak", thus "Oak-land". If someone could come up with something to put between aec and land it could perhaps be refined further. | Lithium-Ion | [2] (talk) |
Anbion | Anbish | Anbian | Anbish | A play on Albion, an ancient alternative name for Britain. No etymology but I'm sure we can invent some! | Pawl (talk) |
Brynland | Brynish | Brynian | Brynish | A Gearmanic mis-hearing and mis-understanding of the Caeltig Bryn y lan (Hill by the shore), which they thought was referring to a whole land and not just a particular hill (similar to "Canada" coming from an Iroquois word for "village"). | Pawl (talk) |
Intherland | Intherish | Intherish | Intherish | It's "Ingerland" but with a "th" instead of a "g". While it's still a pretty obvious England ripoff, it's far less egregious than before, and could possibly have an etymology related to "Hinterland" or, like England, the Inther people - whoever they are. | Lithium-Ion | [3] (talk) |