Forum:Territory application/AR021 - Polska: Difference between revisions

Latest revision as of 17:30, 19 October 2023

Forums → Territory application → Territory application/AR021 - Polska

Please fill in the information below to make a territory request.

	Territory ID and proposed name
	The Territory ID (from OpenGeofiction:Territories, e.g. AR123a) and proposed name of the country

AR021 - Polska

	Physical geography
	An overview of climate, topography and landscape of the country. It is advised to also create a sketch, you can add a link to this (hosted on imgur or similar)

Temperate climate, mainly lowlands, only a few mountains in the south, landscape similar to that in Poland (I will implement my project "Fictional Poland" in these areas)

	Human geography
	A brief description of the territory demographics, economic development, land occupation, infrastructure and mapping style

The rules are more or less like in Poland, i.e. the poor east and the rich west, more or less everything is Polish style.

In this area there will be a fictional Poland project, which aims to build a new map of this country, with different city names, etc. However, there will be some inserts from the Polish area, due to the fact that it is similar to the Polish one.

	History & culture
	A brief description of the intended culture and language

Everything like in Poland.

	Past mapping
	To support your request provide links to areas of OGF mapping which showcase your mapping skill. Mapping relevant to the requested theme & geography is especially useful
	The {{coord}} template can optionally be used to link to the OGF map - it results in a nice formatted link. Or you can paste in a URL.

I think I'm doing pretty good at mapping, but I'll have to work on the scale (but I'll pay special attention to it now).

	Username & date
	Sign and date the application by typing four tildes like this: ~~~~

—Unsigned comment by Ksawery2137 (talk).

	Discussion
	Discussion for clarification & decision

I apologize in advance for any mistakes, but everything is from the translator.

Territory application closed

Sorry, I cannot approve this application. There are a few problems.

The requested territory is identified on the territory map as "... a desert climate; most of the population will be in the north" and similarly at OpenGeofiction:Territory application#North and South Archanta it has the broad themes of African and desert. A broad Polish theme, with Polish climate, is clearly not compatible with these themes and the geographical location of the territory. I would suggest you look at Uletha, around the UL13* and UL14* territories.
No sketch map was provided, and in general the application limited in scope.
While we clearly have territories strongly inspired by real-world countries, I feel your intention was even more of a "copy" of Poland than is acceptable.
Your history of rule breaking means there is no mapping for us to consider. You will need to build up mapping in the blue territories (e.g. BG01), or request a Beginner territory, first.

Thanks/wangi (talk) 17:30, 19 October 2023 (UTC)

The following resources can be useful in building up mapping experience: Help:Portal, Help:Making realistic countries, Help:Making realistic cities and also OpenGeofiction:Site policies

@@ Line 19: / Line 19: @@
 The rules are more or less like in Poland, i.e. the poor east and the rich west, more or less everything is Polish style.
+In this area there will be a fictional Poland project, which aims to build a new map of this country, with different city names, etc. However, there will be some inserts from the Polish area, due to the fact that it is similar to the Polish one.
 {{territory application history and culture}}
-Everything like in Poland
+Everything like in Poland.
 {{territory application past mapping}}
@@ Line 30: / Line 32: @@
 {{territory application username and date}}
-WRITE HERE
+{{unsigned|Ksawery2137}}
-{{territory application discussion}}In this area there will be a fictional Poland project, which aims to build a new map of this country, with different city names, etc. However, there will be some inserts from the Polish area, due to the fact that it is similar to the Polish one.
+{{territory application discussion}}
 I apologize in advance for any mistakes, but everything is from the translator.
-*
+{{territory application closed|Sorry, I cannot approve this application. There are a few problems.
-<!-- replace this with {{territory application approved|summary of decision and signature|optionally useful information for the user}} or {{territory application closed|summary of decision and signature|optionally useful information for the user}} on closing -->
+# The requested territory is identified on the [[OpenGeofiction:Territories#Overview Map|territory map]] as ''"... a desert climate; most of the population will be in the north"'' and similarly at [[OpenGeofiction:Territory application#North and South Archanta]] it has the broad themes of African and desert. A broad Polish theme, with Polish climate, is clearly not compatible with these themes and the geographical location of the territory. I would suggest you look at Uletha, around the UL13* and UL14* territories.
-{{territory application in progress}}
+# No sketch map was provided, and in general the application limited in scope.
+# While we clearly have territories strongly inspired by real-world countries, I feel your intention was even more of a "copy" of Poland than is acceptable.
+# Your history of rule breaking means there is no mapping for us to consider. You will need to build up mapping in the blue territories (e.g. BG01), or request a Beginner territory, first.
+Thanks/[[User:Wangi|wangi]] ([[User talk:Wangi|talk]]) 17:30, 19 October 2023 (UTC)
+}}